Shorts, Lehman and Price Discovery

An article in the Wall Street Journal makes the point that short sellers help price discovery and cites the example of David Einhorn's (correct) criticism of Lehman Brothers in Spring 2008.
But what does this article prove? That the world should thank Einhorn for helping to precipitate the collapse of Lehman Brothers? If the short sellers have such a big heart they should just state their concerns and hope that management or the other shareholders - who are the ultimate controllers of a company - act upon the advice. That is at least what one would expect a responsible owner to do. One look at the share register of most listed companies makes it clear that most companies are effectively controlled by the same small circle of large institutional investors (BlackRock, Fidelity etal) and in a rational world it should not be beyond the power of the highly-qualified and well-paid professionals among their staff to be responsible guardians of the investor's interest. These firms are the ultimate force behind nearly all of corporate America (and by extension the World) and they can no longer hide behind arcane regulations or passing the buck to the governments.

0 comments:

Post a Comment